Symptom
Most likely cause
Fix
Overload trips on start or under load
Overloads set wrong for the nameplate FLA (most common after a motor swap), supply voltage low or unbalanced, mechanical bind in the compressor, or an undersized starter for the motor.
Verify the overload setting matches the NEW motor nameplate FLA, not the old setting, not the breaker. Measure voltage on all three phases at the motor under load; low or unbalanced supply mimics an overload fault. Rule out a seized airend or over-tensioned belts before replacing the starter.
Contactor chatters or won't pull in
Wrong or failing coil, low control voltage, a failed seal-in (holding) auxiliary contact, or a control-transformer problem.
Confirm the coil voltage matches the control circuit and measure the actual control voltage at the coil. Check the seal-in aux contact and the start/stop circuit. Replace the coil or the starter if the coil is burned.
Contacts pitted, welded, or burned
Normal end-of-life from repeated arcing, or accelerated wear from undersizing, hard cycling, or an IEC starter on a load that needed NEMA margin. Welded tips can no longer break the line.
Replace the starter (or the contact kit where the line supports it). If contacts are wearing fast, step up to a NEMA size or a higher utilization category for the cycling rate. Welded contacts are a safety issue; the line can't be opened.
Motor hums, then trips (single-phasing)
One phase lost, blown fuse, broken lead, or a failed / pitted contactor pole that isn't making. The motor can't develop starting torque and draws locked-rotor current on the remaining phases.
Check for voltage on all three phases on both sides of the contactor. A pole that has line voltage in but nothing out is a failed contact, replace the starter. Confirm the overload relay has working single-phasing / phase-loss protection so it trips before the motor cooks.
New motor burned out shortly after a swap
The old starter's overloads were never re-rated to the new nameplate FLA, or a worn contactor single-phased the new motor. The starter killed the new motor.
On any motor replacement, re-rate the overloads to the new nameplate FLA and inspect the contacts, replace the starter if the tips are pitted or the overload range no longer brackets the new FLA. Standard practice: quote a fresh starter with every motor.